Despite compelling testimony, ACC and TEP again snub rural and tribal communities harmed economically from early coal plant closures

Logo of Tó Nizhóní Ání “Sacred Water Speaks”

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:

Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026

CONTACT:

  • Nicole Horseherder, Tó Nizhóní Ání, nicole@tonizhoniani.org, 928-675-1851
  • Mike Eisenfeld, San Juan Citizens Alliance, mike@sanjuancitizens.org, 505-360-8994
  • Chanele Reyes, Arizona Center for Law in the Public Interest, chanele@aclpi.org, 602-258-8850

Despite compelling testimony, ACC and TEP again snub rural and tribal communities harmed economically from early coal plant closures

PHOENIX, Ariz – In the culmination today of a rate increase proceeding for Tucson Electric Power (TEP), the utility and the Arizona Corporation Commission both turned their backs – again – on rural and tribal communities that helped power Arizona’s growth for more than a half century.

In its rate increase request submitted late last year, TEP made no effort to propose any coal community transition (CCT)  assistance to communities still reeling from the deep economic impacts of the company’s boardroom decisions to close down coal plants in which it has ownership far ahead of schedule. Nor did it commit to building any new generating resources on tribal land, despite earning untold millions in profits from its stakes in Navajo Generating Station (NGS), San Juan Generating Station and Four Corners Power Plant.

As intervenors in the TEP proceeding – as well as previous rate cases dating back to 2019, the year NGS was closed –  Tó Nizhóni Ání (TNA) and San Juan Citizens Alliance (SJCA) submitted detailed testimony highlighting the need for transition assistance, the company’s corporate obligation to provide it, and the Commission’s authority and past precedent in ordering it. This Commission, however, ignored all the evidence and casually dismissed the request for transition assistance without any discussion.

“For TEP and the Commission to both continue pretending that they don’t have a responsibility to lend a hand to communities that helped build Arizona is disgraceful,” said TNA’s executive director, Nicole Horseherder. “They have both failed the Navajo Nation, the Hopi Tribe and the communities in the Four Corners region. They’ve exploited our resources for decades, and now they’re turning their backs and walking away.”

In several previous proceedings, the Commission has approved plans for Arizona Public Service (APS) to provide more than $14 million in transition assistance to coal-impacted communities. APS also committed to developing 600 megawatts of replacement clean energy on tribal land. TEP has made no such commitment, neither providing any transition funding nor developing new clean energy projects on tribal land despite issuing several requests for proposals for adding new resources over the past seven years.

TEP insists that it supports the concept of transition and would be open to providing assistance, but the lack of a formal framework approved by the ACC prevents it from doing so. For TNA and SJCA, that rings as a hollow excuse since APS was able to provide CCT funding and commitments without a framework in place.

“They take and they take and don’t give anything back,” said Mike Eisenfeld, SJCA’s energy program director. “TEP clearly isn’t going to stand up and meet its obligations without being forced. Maybe the two newly elected ACC commissioners will finally recognize the corporate responsibility that utilities have when they pull the rug out from communities that have become dependent on coal and that have helped them realize millions in profit.”

NGS, the largest coal-fired power plant in the West, was retired in 2019, more than two decades earlier than it was supposed to, after the owners, including TEP, decided it was no longer economical to operate. In the wake of the abrupt closure, the Navajo Nation and the Hopi Tribe collectively experienced cuts of hundreds of millions of dollars in tax revenue and coal royalties that they expected to continue flowing into the 2040s, not to mention the loss of nearly a thousand high-paying jobs. Seven years later, both tribes are still recovering from the hole left by the lost revenue.

“Little has changed since NGS was closed down,” said Chanele Reyes, the attorney at Arizona Center for Law in the Public Interest who represented the groups in the TEP proceeding. “Coal plants are still being retired far earlier than planned, and even though the Commission has recognized in previous rulings that utilities have a corporate responsibility to provide transition support to communities, they keep turning their backs on them. These communities have fueled Arizona’s growth and prosperity. They are extremely vulnerable, and the Commission seems to think it’s acceptable to let them fall off an economic cliff.”

###

More detailed information on coal community transition is available in the testimony submitted in this proceeding by TNA and SJCA, here and here.

Adrian Herder

Adrian grew up with the organization, and in 2020 he joined Tó Nizhóní Ání full-time and is now in charge of the organization's creative direction. He is from the community of Hardrock, AZ, located on Black Mesa (Dził Yíjiin). Adrian graduated from Northern Arizona University and is passionate about storytelling, the arts, advocacy, and making an impact.

Categories